While I am sure that there are other good rates out there, we consistently get great service and very good rates in Italy from AutoEurope. Everything is included in the prepaid, and cancellable rate, and we have enjoyed doing business with them. Actually, they are very easy to work with. You can have your choice of pick up and drop off places and no matter where we have used them in Italy, it hasn't been a problem.

Right now, they have a 15% off sale on bookings made by April 30. Here is a website:

http://www.autoeurope.com/

Good Luck, Debbie in Pittsburgh