For romance, I'd choose Anse Chastenet in St. Lucia. The resort is nestled in the hills with secluded rooms accessed by steps from the main lodge. Two private beaches add to the sense of "being away". The resort website has a feature called "Do Nothing" so you know that you can actually do nothing and enjoy yourself. Winter has a firm grip on Toronto today so if I could return to this lush island get-away it would be a fine place to be on Valentine's Day. http://www.ansechastanet.com/

Lucy, Toronto